Psychology Nature Is Weird

Sleep deprivation doesn't just make you more suggestible; it specifically targets and breaks down your most confident beliefs.

April 1, 2026

Original Paper

Sleep Deprivation Disrupts the Gatekeeping Role of Confidence in Belief Updating

Charlotte Anckaert, Philippe Peigneux, Wim Gevers

PsyArXiv · zskx3_v1

The Takeaway

Usually, the more certain you are about a belief, the harder it is for someone to change your mind. However, after 24 hours without sleep, this 'confidence shield' disappears, making your most deeply held convictions just as easy to sway as your random guesses.

From the abstract

Belief updating in response to social feedback is essential for adaptive decision-making, but may be sensitive to sleep deprivation. Across two preregistered within-subjects studies (N = 36, conducted in 2023, and N = 49, conducted in 2024), we examined how 24 hours of total sleep deprivation affects belief change and confidence updating after agreeing or disagreeing peer feedback. Sleep deprivation consistently increased belief change, regardless of feedback type, and disrupted the stabilizing